The vast majority of businesses in the United States are privately held, and approximately 99 percent meet a common government definition of "small." However, we know surprisingly little about the market values of these organizations. In this paper, we estimate the market value of privately held firms in the United States from sources on earnings, assets, and reported market value of multiple forms of business entities,
including corporations, partnerships, LLCs, and sole proprietorships. We discuss various theoretical and practical methods of valuing assets, including those arising from economics, neoclassical finance, portfolio theory, and tradition. Concluding that most of them are not appropriate for valuing private firms, we use insights from dynamic programming and ratio analyses from traditional technique to produce a new estimate based on reported taxable earnings, net worth, and tax filing status. Using this approach, we estimate that privately held U.S. firms had earnings that exceeded those of publicly held firms in two recent years by a significant margin. Moreover, the market value of these firms exceeded that of publicly traded firms. We also conclude that policymakers, perhaps grossly, underestimate the true scale of "small" and privately held firms in the economy.
Ignorance of the market value of privately held companies also undermines many of the practices of modern finance, in which the stock market is used as a proxy for the total value of investment assets. In particular, the Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM) and other descendents of the mean-variance framework rely heavily on a simplifying assumption about investments: that the stock market serves as a valid proxy for the universe of equity investments available, and therefore the risks and returns of publicly traded stocks are the relevant focus of portfolio decisions by these investors. This will be discussed further below.
In this paper, we assemble data from a variety of sources on the assets, revenue, and earnings of privately held firms. Using these data, and employing a mixture of techniques, we estimate the market value of privately held firms in the United States, which may be the most important economic statistics for which there are no direct empirical data. We also demonstrate a methodology to revise this estimate in the future, and offer some suggestions for improving it.
No comments:
Post a Comment